| Duxbury | Chris Walsh | 2023 | SS | |
| Duxbury | Ryan Flaherty | 2022 | 2B | |
| Duxbury | Nick Ayres | 2023 | 3B/1B | |
| Hanover | Gabe Knudsen | 2024 | P/1B | |
| Hanover | Evan Hebblethwaite | 2022 | P | |
| Hingham | Jeremy Aylward | 2024 | SS | |
| Hingham | Aiden Devlin | 2024 | CF | |
| Hingham | Jake Schulte | 2023 | P | |
| Hingham | Bobby Falvey | 2022 | 3B | |
| Marshfield | Jack Keane | 2023 | P | |
| North Quincy | John Lynch | 2022 | C | |
| Pembroke | Cody Cantino | 2022 | IN/P | |
| Pembroke | Aidan Blake | 2023 | OF | |
| Plymouth North | Alec Peruzzi | 2022 | P/OF | |
| Plymouth North | Conner Vercollone | 2022 | CF/P | |
| Plymouth North | Mark McKay | 2023 | C | |
| Plymouth North | Connor MacKenzie | 2023 | 3B | |
| Plymouth North | Cam Champney | 2023 | P/1B | |
| Plymouth South | Tommy Sullivan | 2022 | RHP | |
| Plymouth South | Naythen Ruehs | 2022 | 2B | |
| Plymouth South | Matt Cassidy | 2022 | SS | |
| Plymouth South | Jack Obert | 2022 | 3B/RHP | |
| Quincy | Drew Boretti | 2022 | P/1B | |
| Quincy | Zach Donaghue | 2022 | P/OF | |
| Quincy | Kellen Kopp | 2022 | SS/2B | |
| Scituate | Jordan Barthel | 2023 | P/DH/OF | |
| Scituate | Dylan McDonald | 2022 | P | |
| Scituate | Ben Whitman | 2022 | SS/P | |
| Scituate | Mike Sheskey | 2022 | 3B | |
| Silver Lake | Chris Quigley | 2022 | P/IF | |
| Whitman Hanson | Aidan Barry | 2022 | 2B/P | |
| Whitman Hanson | Ethan Smith | 2022 | 1b/P | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| School | Sportsmanship (individual) | | | |
| Duxbury | Tyler Proukou | | | |
| Hanover | Christian Henderson | | | |
| Hingham | Bennett Cashman | | | |
| Marshfield | Zac Chandler | | | |
| North Quincy | Carson Douglas | | | |
| Pembroke | Nolan Holloway | | | |
| Plymouth North | Jacob Petrarca | | | |
| Plymouth South | AJ DelPozzo | | | |
| Quincy | Dylan Green | | | |
| Scituate | Brendan Boyle | | | |
| Silver Lake | Jensen Benevides | | | |
| Whitman Hanson | Jayden Booker | | | |
| | | | |
| Keenan MVP | Alec Peruzzi , Plymouth North | | | |
| Fisher MVP | Tommy Sullivan, Plymouth South | | | |
| Keenan Sportsmanship | Marshfield | | | |
| Fisher Sportsmanship | Scituate | | | |
| | | |
